How do I accept or reject the changes reviewers propose to title, topic or keywords?

Let reviewers propose a better title, other topics or keywords while they rate, and decide on each proposal in one place.

Article Image Alt

Why reviewers propose changes

Reviewers often notice things while they read: a title that does not say what the study is about, an abstract filed under the wrong topic, keywords that are missing. Instead of writing this into a comment that nobody acts on, a reviewer can make a proposal, and you accept or reject it with one click.

The authors never see the proposals. If you accept one, the change is made to the session at once.

Step 1: Add proposal questions to the rating form

Reviewers can only propose changes if the rating form asks for them. In the rating form, add a question for each kind of proposal you want:

  • a question marked Proposed title, for a better title;
  • a question marked Proposed labels, for other topics or labels;
  • a question marked Proposed keywords, for keywords.

Mark each question in its settings in the form editor, then save a version and publish the form. See How do I build a rating form with weighted criteria and instructions for reviewers?.

With Five icons instead of a rating form, reviewers cannot propose changes.

Step 2: Let the reviewers rate

Reviewers answer the proposal questions while they rate. Most will leave them empty; that is expected.

Step 3: Decide on the proposals

  1. Open Content And Speakers, then Sessions, and open the abstract.
  2. On its tab Info, in the section with the reviews, find the card Proposals. It lists each proposal with the reviewer who made it.
  3. For each proposal, choose Accept or Reject.

A session's Info tab with the card Proposals: a reviewer's proposed title, with Accept and Reject

Accept changes the session at once: the title, the labels or the keywords. Reject leaves the session as it is.

Things to consider

  • The title is the author's. Many congresses accept a proposed title only after asking the author. If you change a title, tell the author, for example in the decision mail.
  • Topics are labels. A proposed topic is a proposed session label. Accepting it adds the label to the session.
  • Do it before the programme. Decide on the proposals before you build the programme, so that sessions sit in the right topic when you group them.

Related articles