Why reviewers propose changes
Reviewers often notice things while they read: a title that does not say what the study is about, an abstract filed under the wrong topic, keywords that are missing. Instead of writing this into a comment that nobody acts on, a reviewer can make a proposal, and you accept or reject it with one click.
The authors never see the proposals. If you accept one, the change is made to the session at once.
Step 1: Add proposal questions to the rating form
Reviewers can only propose changes if the rating form asks for them. In the rating form, add a question for each kind of proposal you want:
- a question marked Proposed title, for a better title;
- a question marked Proposed labels, for other topics or labels;
- a question marked Proposed keywords, for keywords.
Mark each question in its settings in the form editor, then save a version and publish the form. See How do I build a rating form with weighted criteria and instructions for reviewers?.
With Five icons instead of a rating form, reviewers cannot propose changes.
Step 2: Let the reviewers rate
Reviewers answer the proposal questions while they rate. Most will leave them empty; that is expected.
Step 3: Decide on the proposals
- Open Content And Speakers, then Sessions, and open the abstract.
- On its tab Info, in the section with the reviews, find the card Proposals. It lists each proposal with the reviewer who made it.
- For each proposal, choose Accept or Reject.
Accept changes the session at once: the title, the labels or the keywords. Reject leaves the session as it is.
Things to consider
- The title is the author's. Many congresses accept a proposed title only after asking the author. If you change a title, tell the author, for example in the decision mail.
- Topics are labels. A proposed topic is a proposed session label. Accepting it adds the label to the session.
- Do it before the programme. Decide on the proposals before you build the programme, so that sessions sit in the right topic when you group them.
Related articles