How do I find the reviews of one abstract when its author asks why it was rejected?

Find the scores and comments of one abstract, and give the author the feedback meant for them, not the committee's internal remarks.

Article Image Alt

The situation

An author writes after the decisions: why was my abstract rejected? Or: why was it accepted as a poster and not as a talk? You want to look at the reviews, and give the author a fair answer.

Step 1: Open the abstract's reviews

  1. Open Content And Speakers, then Sessions.
  2. Search for the title, or the author's name, and open the abstract.
  3. Stay on the tab Info. Its section with the reviews shows each reviewer's score and recommendation, and lets you open each full review.

As a content admin, you can also download Review summary (PDF), with all reviews of the abstract in one document.

A session's Info tab, with the scores of its reviews, the weighted average and Review summary (PDF)

Step 2: Separate what the author may read

A review holds two kinds of answers:

  • the answer to the question marked Comment to the author, which was written for the author;
  • all other answers, which were written for the committee and may be blunt, or name things the author should not see.

The review summary and the tab Info show both. Do not forward them to the author unchecked.

Step 3: Give the author the comments meant for them

The clean way is to release the comments to the author. They then read exactly what the reviewers wrote for them, with the reviewers shown as "Reviewer 1", "Reviewer 2".

  1. Open the abstract's tab Author discussion.
  2. Open Discussion actions and choose Release comments.

The author is informed by e-mail and reads the comments in their speaker dashboard. If your presentation type lets authors reply, they can answer there.

If your congress releases the comments to all authors with the decision, the author can already read them. Point them to Discussion on their session card.

When there are no comments

If the presentation type was rated with Five icons, there are only icon ratings, without written reasons. Then answer the author yourself, with the committee's general reasons, for example the number of abstracts against the number of slots.

Related articles