What the authors can read
Many congresses give authors the reviewers' feedback: why the abstract was accepted as a poster, what to improve before the presentation, or why it was rejected. Some go further and let the authors answer, so that a misunderstanding can be cleared before the decision.
In run.events, the authors read only what the reviewers wrote in the question marked Comment to the author. All other answers of the rating form stay internal. In a blind review, the authors see the reviewers as "Reviewer 1", "Reviewer 2".
This works with a rating form only. With Five icons, there are no comments to the author.
Before you start
Your rating form needs a question marked Comment to the author. See How do I build a rating form with weighted criteria and instructions for reviewers?. Tell your reviewers that the author may read this answer.
Step 1: Decide when the comments are released
- Open Presentation Types, choose the presentation type, and open its tab Forms.
- Under Comments to the author, choose when the authors can read them:
- never, which is the default;
- when the speakers are informed of the decision: the authors read the comments together with the decision;
- as soon as a review is submitted: the authors read each comment as it comes, during the review.
- Save.
Step 2: Let the authors reply, if you want
On the same tab:
- Tick Authors may reply.
- Enter the Reply window (days): how many days after the release the authors can answer.
- Save.
What the authors see
When the comments are released, the authors are informed by e-mail. On their speaker dashboard, Needs your attention lists "Read the reviewers' new messages", and the session card offers Discussion. There they read the comments and, while the reply window is open, write their answer. You and the reviewers read the answers on the session's tab Author discussion.
Release the comments of one abstract by hand
You can release the comments of a single abstract at any time, whatever the setting says. This is useful when an author asks why their abstract was rejected.
- Open the abstract on Sessions.
- Open its tab Author discussion.
- Open Discussion actions and choose Release comments.
In the same menu, Extend reply window gives the authors of this abstract more time to answer.
Good to know: read the comments before you release them. Reviewers sometimes write remarks meant for the committee into the comment to the author. Once released, the authors can read them.
Related articles