How do I pass a concern about an abstract to the committee?

For reviewers: tell the committee that an abstract looks already published, overlaps with another, or belongs to another topic.

Article Image Alt

When you have a concern

While reviewing, you may notice more than the quality of an abstract: the results look already published, the abstract is almost the same as another one, or it was submitted under the wrong topic. run.events has no button to report such a case, but there are three places to write it, each read by different people.

1. An internal question in the rating form

If the congress's rating form has a question for the committee, for example "Remarks for the committee", write your concern there. Only the organizers read it; the authors and the other reviewers do not.

This is the right place for a concern about plagiarism or prior publication. Say what you found and where, for example the journal and year of an earlier paper.

2. The tab Comments

Each abstract has a tab Comments, the internal discussion of the congress's team. It reads "Visible to the content team. Your name is shown." Everyone in the team can read it, including the other reviewers who open the abstract, and your name appears with your comment.

Use it for questions you want to discuss with the other reviewers, not for concerns about an author's honesty.

The Comments tab of a session as a reviewer sees it

3. A proposal, for a wrong topic, title or keywords

If the rating form asks for proposals, you can propose another topic, a better title or other keywords while you rate. The organizers accept or reject each proposal; the authors never see it.

Which to use

Your concern Where
The results seem already published, or copied The rating form's internal question
The abstract is almost the same as another one The rating form's internal question, naming the other abstract
The abstract is under the wrong topic A proposal, if the form has one; otherwise the internal question
A question for the other reviewers The tab Comments

With five icons instead of a rating form, there is no internal question and no proposal. Use the tab Comments, or write to the organizers directly.

Related articles