How do I rate an abstract?

For reviewers: read the abstract, fill in the rating form or choose an icon, save a draft, submit, and change a review later.

Article Image Alt

Two ways congresses rate

Each congress decides how its abstracts are rated:

  • With a rating form: several questions, such as originality and scientific quality on a scale, a recommendation, and a comment to the author. Most scientific congresses use this.
  • With five icons: you choose one of five icons for each abstract. It is quick, without criteria or comments.

You see which one when you open an abstract.

Step 1: Read the abstract

Open the abstract from your list. Its tab Info shows the abstract, part by part, and the other answers the authors gave, including any files. To read on paper or offline, choose Abstract sheet (PDF): one abstract at a time, as a blind copy in a double-blind review.

Step 2a: Rate with a rating form

  1. Open the tab Rating. Above the questions, the congress's instructions explain how to rate. Under each question, a short description may explain it.
  2. Answer the questions page by page.
  3. To stop and continue later, choose Save draft. Each change of page saves a draft as well. A draft does not count yet.
  4. When you are done, choose Submit review.

The tab then reads "Submitted on …", with the date.

The Rating tab as a reviewer sees it, with the rating form's questions

What each part of the form is for

  • The criteria make up the abstract's score. Use the whole scale.
  • The recommendation says what you think should happen: accept, accept as another kind of contribution such as a poster, or reject.
  • The comment to the author may be shown to the authors later, without your name. Write it so that it helps them.
  • Other questions, for example remarks for the committee, are read by the organizers only.

Step 2b: Rate with five icons

On the tab Info, under Stats, choose the rating button and one of the five icons. Your choice is saved at once.

With five icons, everyone who opens the abstract sees the average, and the icons the other reviewers chose, with their names.

Changing a review

While the congress's review is open, open the abstract again and choose Update review. Change your answers and submit again. Once your comment to the author has been released to the authors, that answer stays as it is.

When the review of an abstract has closed, the tab reads "Reviews are closed for this session", and you can no longer change anything.

What you cannot do

  • You cannot download all your abstracts at once; the abstract sheet works one abstract at a time.
  • With a rating form, you see only your own review. The other reviews of the same abstract are for the organizers.

Related articles