How do I see which reviewers are behind?

Follow the review on the Review dashboard, find the reviewers who are late, and remind them.

Article Image Alt

Where you follow the review

In the weeks before the decision, the question is always the same: how far is the review, and who is late? The Review dashboard answers it.

Open Content And Speakers and, under Report, choose Review.

Step 1: See how far the review is

At the top, two rings show the overall state:

  • Reviews done of needed: how many of the reviews your stages need have been submitted.
  • Sessions in review: how many abstracts are fully reviewed, how many are waiting for reviews, and how many need attention. An abstract needs attention when it has fewer reviews than needed, an overdue review, or reviewers who disagree.

Step 2: See what is still open

Open items shows bars such as Reviews not done, each with the number that is overdue. Choose a bar, and the Sessions page opens, filtered on exactly those abstracts.

Step 3: See who is late

Reviewer workload shows each reviewer as a bar: assigned, in progress, done, overdue and declined reviews, against their limits. A red outline marks a reviewer with an overdue review. Under their minimum lists the reviewers who have not yet done the number of reviews you expect from them. Choose a name to open that reviewer's settings.

The Review dashboard, with the progress of the review and the reviewers' workload

You see the same numbers on the card Content Team under Configure, in the columns Assigned, Done and Overdue.

Step 4: Remind the reviewers who are late

run.events has no reminder for reviewers, and the dashboard has no button to write to them. Send Email To Speakers and the e-mail in Speaker Management reach speakers, not reviewers. So you remind late reviewers from your own mailbox:

  1. Note the reviewers with overdue reviews, or under their minimum, from Reviewer workload.
  2. Write to them from your own e-mail, with the number of reviews still open, the due date, and the way in: the card Reviewer on their start page, button My reviews.

The exports of Content Team and Event Team do not include e-mail addresses, so keep your committee's addresses in your own list.

Step 5: Act if a reviewer will not finish

If a reviewer cannot finish, give their abstracts to someone else. See How do I replace the reviewer of an abstract?.

Good to know: the due date only marks reviews as overdue. Reviewers can still rate after it. If you need to stop all rating in a bucket, for example on the morning of the decision meeting, tick Lock ratings on the bucket.

Related articles